Rating Guidelines and Content Policy

What makes a good review and what content is not allowed.

Rating Scale

When rating a vendor, use the full 1–5 star scale to reflect your honest experience:

  • 5 stars — Excellent. Outstanding product quality, fast shipping, great communication, everything as expected or better.
  • 4 stars — Good. Solid experience with minor issues that didn't significantly impact your satisfaction.
  • 3 stars — Average. Acceptable but with noticeable room for improvement. Mixed experience.
  • 2 stars — Poor. Significant issues with product quality, shipping, communication, or accuracy.
  • 1 star — Terrible. Major problems, unacceptable experience, or a complete failure to deliver.

What Makes a Good Review

  • Based on real experience — Only review vendors you have actually purchased from
  • Specific and detailed — Mention products by name, describe shipping times, packaging, and product quality
  • Honest and balanced — Include both positives and negatives; no vendor is perfect
  • Relevant photos — Product images, packaging, shipping condition, or lab results

Prohibited Content

Reviews that contain any of the following will be rejected during moderation:

  • Fake or fabricated reviews — Reviews not based on actual purchase experience
  • Spam or promotional content — Advertising, referral links, or self-promotion
  • Profanity or personal attacks — Directed at vendors, staff, or other reviewers
  • Competitor disparagement — Reviews written primarily to harm a competitor
  • Conflict of interest — Reviewing your own business or a direct competitor
  • Irrelevant content — Reviews that don't relate to the vendor's products or services

Photos Policy

Uploaded photos must be relevant to your review: product images, packaging, shipping condition, or lab test results. Do not upload photos containing personal information, inappropriate content, or images unrelated to the review.

Appeals: If your review is rejected and you believe the decision was incorrect, contact us at support@amino.reviews with your review details and we'll take another look.
PreviousEditing or Deleting Your ReviewNext Creating a Reviewer Profile